Books

Book Review: Alchemy of Secrets

I have read Stephanie Garber’s Caravel series and her Once Upon a Broken Heart series (though I still need to read the latest book that just came out) so I am used to her upper YA fantasy/magical love stories. When I heard last year that she was coming out with an adult contemporary fantasy novel, I was instantly intrigued. I promptly pre-ordered Alchemy of Secrets and then let it sit on my bookshelf for a year as one does. I just finished it a couple days ago!

The novel takes place during present day in LA. The main character Holland St. James is a grad student studying folklore. When she was an undergrad she took a secret course, a course that isn’t listed in any course catalogs but you find out about from word of mouth and if you figure out where the classes are the professor will tell you about different mysterious tales, legends, and myths primarily in the LA/Hollywood area and at the end of the semester a grade will show up on your transcript. Holland is fascinated by all the myths and trying to find out if they are true, like the one about finding the Watch Man who can tell you when you are going to die or the one about how the devil drinks at one of the hotel bars in LA and if you find him and buy him a sidecar, he will grant you a wish.

Holland her friends who also took the secret folklore class are really into it and all the old Hollywood tales, but what no one knows is Holland’s last name isn’t really St. James. Her parents were famous in Hollywood. Her mother was an actress and her father a director and screenwriter who both died tragically when Holland her twin sister, January, were kids. The more Holland learns, the more she thinks her parents might have been somehow involved in these magical tales.

When, the Professor goes missing and Holland’s advisor is replaced with a mysterious young man named Adam Bishop, things start to get really weird. Adam tells Holland not to believe what the Professor has told her. Gabe, another mysterious man who shows up, tells her he was sent by her sister to protect her and not to trust Adam. Adam tells her not to trust Gabe and that he knows her sister too. Oh and the Watch Man tells her she has until midnight tomorrow night to figure out a certain mystery or she will die…

Can she figure out the mystery? And who can she trust, if anyone?

This novel was really interesting and I was really hooked on it. The short chapters also helped me move through the story quickly. However, I couldn’t figure out what was going on or who was good or bad, which can be great if you don’t want to be able to guess everything. But, but the end of the book I still couldn’t figure out what was going to happen or who was good or bad! I like twists and turns but this one just seemed to constantly go back and forth between “Trust Adam, not Gabe. Trust Gabe not Adam” over and over again. I also wish there were some more clear answers in the end. There is going to be a sequel to this, but still I wish we got more answers in this first book.

Overall, I was really interested in this book! I just wish there were some more answers. I am looking forward to hopefully getting some more answers in the next book!

Read this if you want a dark, mystery urban fantasy with thriller, dark academia and magical realism vibes.

*This post contains affiliate links.*

Welcome to my blog! I'm a teacher during the day and lifestyle blogger by night. I love pop culture, entertainment/TV/movies/music, food, beauty, travel & fashion! www.twitter.com/jamwong www.instagram.com/lifeaccordingtojamie

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.